Bloom’s Taxonomy, first introduced by Benjamin Bloom (1956) and later revised by Anderson and Krathwohl (2001), outlines six hierarchical levels of cognitive complexity. These levels - often visualised as a stairway - encourage learners to progress from basic recall to advanced critical thinking and problem-solving.
Remember: Recall facts and basic concepts
Understand: Explain ideas or concepts
Apply: Use information in new situations
Analyse: Draw connections among ideas
Evaluate: Justify decisions or actions
Create: Produce original work or solutions
In the context of Incident Command training, Bloom’s Taxonomy highlights a critical gap between quantitative and qualitative competencies:
Quantitative Assessments (e.g., written exams) typically measure only the lower tiers: Remember and Understand.
Qualitative Competence is required when incidents present unexpected challenges beyond standard procedures - demanding commanders to Create bespoke solutions using judgment, experience, and situational awareness.
This gap is especially concerning as incident frequency declines (Knight, 2013; Home Office, 2019), reducing real-world exposure and leaving commanders underprepared for high-stakes decision-making.
Retention of Organisational Knowledge
Including culture, doctrine, policy, and procedures (Brunacini, 2002)
Decisive Action Under Pressure: The ability to make and execute decisions in time-critical, high-consequence environments (Hutton & Klein, 1999)
Mastery of Non-Technical Skills: Often referred to as behavioral markers, these include leadership, communication, and judgment. As defined by Klampfer et al. (2001): “Observable, non-technical behaviours that contribute to a superior or substandard performance within a work environment.”
These skills are central to high-reliability industries and are best developed through simulation-based training, structured observation, and reflective debriefing—as documented by Crichton (2017).
______________________________________________________________________________________
Effective Command is more than just a training system – it is a recognised behavioural marker framework designed to develop and assess the non-technical skills essential for incident command. Created in 2015 by fire service practitioners and academics from the UK and Australia, it bridges the gap between operational practice and academic research.
A behavioural marker framework identifies observable, non-technical behaviours that contribute to effective or substandard performance in high-risk environments. These markers are used to:
Structure training scenarios
Guide performance observation
Deliver targeted feedback
Support formal assessment and qualification
As Klampfer et al. (2001) describe, these markers help assess “observable, non-technical behaviours that contribute to a superior or substandard performance within a work environment.”
Situational Awareness: Understanding the evolving incident environment
Decision-Making: Making timely, assertive choices under pressure
Objective Setting: Defining clear goals to guide team actions
Action Behaviours: Leading decisively and coordinating resources
Review: Reflecting on performance for continuous improvement
Within the Effective Command software, these five behaviours are further subdivided into eight sections, forming the backbone of structured observation and feedback.
Training: Scenarios are designed to elicit specific behaviours, which are then observed and discussed during debriefs.
Monitoring: Live incidents are audited using the framework to assess command performance.
Assessment: Post-incident / scenario reviews and case studies are evaluated against behavioural criteria for qualifications or audits.
All of these options can subsequently be recorded using specific reports available directly within the Effective Command software
By focusing on how commanders behave - not just what they know - Effective Command ensures that training is relevant, repeatable, and aligned with real-world demands. It supports high-reliability decision-making and helps organisations justify training investments with evidence-based insights.
If you would like assistance mapping these behaviours to leadership development goals or integrating them into a training curriculum then this can also be arranged through the Effective Command software.
______________________________________________________________________________________
The Effective Command methodology is a simulation-based approach designed to develop non-technical command skills through structured, scenario-driven learning. It aligns with Crichton’s (2017) five principles of team training and is enriched by Kolb’s four-stage learning cycle, which promotes deeper understanding through experience, reflection, conceptualisation, and experimentation.
Principle 1: Develop Learning Objectives & Performance Standards
Kolb Stage: Concrete Experience
Scenarios present unexpected dilemmas (Sarna, 2002; Lamb, 2014), creating immersive experiences that stimulate key command behaviours. These experiences form the foundation for learning and activate relevant behavioural markers.
Principle 2: Train the Team or Individuals
Kolb Stage: Reflective Observation
Participants reflect on their actions and decisions - often overlooked in traditional incident commanders' development. Structured debriefs and peer discussion encourage critical thinking and self-awareness.
Principle 3: Use a Structured Observation Tool
Kolb Stage: Abstract Conceptualisation
The Effective Command framework captures observed behaviours and informs feedback. Learners connect their experiences to theoretical models, policies, and best practices—transforming reflection into actionable insight.
Principle 4: Provide Feedback During a Structured Debrief
Kolb Stage: Active Experimentation
Immediate, face-to-face feedback allows learners to test new strategies and refine their approach in future exercises. This stage encourages adaptation and innovation in command decision-making.
Principle 5: Repeat the Training Regularly
Kolb Cycle: Continuous Application
Embedding the methodology into station drills, live incident monitoring, and large-scale exercises ensures ongoing development. Learners cycle through Kolb’s stages repeatedly, reinforcing skills and building operational resilience.
______________________________________________________________________________________
Bloom, B. S. (1956). Taxonomy of Educational Objectives: The Classification of Educational Goals. Handbook I: Cognitive Domain. New York: David McKay Company.
Brunacini, A. V. (2002). Command Safety. Washington, DC: International Association of Fire Chiefs.
Crichton, M. T. (2017). Command Decision-Making in High-Risk Environments: Non-Technical Skills in Fire Service Training. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 25(4), 314–322.
Hutton, R. J. B., & Klein, G. (1999). Naturalistic Decision Making in Command and Control. In Naturalistic Decision Making (pp. 233–248). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Klampfer, B., Flin, R., Helmreich, R., et al. (2001). Enhancing Performance in High-Risk Environments: Recommendations for the Use of Behavioural Markers. European Commission Report.
Knight, S. (2013). Facing the Future: Findings from the Review of Efficiencies and Operations in Fire and Rescue Authorities in England. London: Home Office.
Kolb, D. A. (1984). Experiential Learning: Experience as the Source of Learning and Development. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Lamb, K., Farrow, M., Olymbios, C., Launder, D., & Greatbatch, I. (2020). Systematic Incident Command Training and Organisational Competence.